Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Only Reed Blood Complete Act 1 of "The Hangman" | 92.2% | |
| Wired Erica saves Scott from the trap | 87.78% | |
| Hanged Complete Act 2 of "The Hangman" | 73.88% | |
| Gumshoe All Q&A puzzles are correctly answered the first time | 67.92% | |
| A Parallel Universe Examine the Scarlet Furies poster | 67.17% | |
| Badaboomdingdang! Help Terence with his problem, and get his help in return | 48.87% | |
| Boston Tea Party Complete Act 3 of "The Hangman" | 48.77% | |
| Not A Witch Successfully complete "The Hangman" | 48.64% | |
 | Hear No Evil Complete the Tess interrogation | 46.49% | 16/02/2018, 12:15:15 |
 | Privacy Violation Sneak a peek in someone else's inbox | 43.52% | 16/02/2018, 12:19:33 |
 | See No Evil Open the puzzle box | 43.42% | |
 | Suffer! Find the Suffer | 43.27% | 16/02/2018, 12:20:01 |
| Pay Your Respects Say goodbye to Davies | 43.13% | |
| Speak No Evil Use a divination device to get Melissa's help | 43.01% | |
| Greedy Bastard Find all the evidence indicating the Dean's corruption | 42.64% | |
| Nothing Gets Past You No wrong answers on the Wise Monkey quiz | 42.61% | |
| Bad Breakup See vision of Kelsey's death | 42.57% | |
| Do No Evil Successfully complete "The Wise Monkey" | 42% | |
| Caffeine Addict Take the coffee from Tess | 41.57% | |
 | The Oracle Unveiled Complete Act 1 of "The Oracle" | 40.36% | |
 | Dear Journal Use the journal to get a hint | 39.96% | 12/11/2019, 17:52:42 |
| Cog-nected Erica and Cordelia make a special connection | 37.45% | |
| Your Secrets Aren't Safe Complete Act 2 of "The Oracle" | 37.28% | |
 | The Past is Prologue Complete Act 1 of "The Cain Killer" | 37.15% | 12/11/2019, 18:07:09 |
| Going Down Complete Act 3 of "The Oracle" | 36.86% | |
| Trip Down Memory Lane Complete all memories in the apartment | 36.76% | |
 | Back in 'Nam Successfully help a friend remember what Bao-Thanh said | 36.58% | 12/11/2019, 18:35:23 |
| I Didn't See This Coming Successfully complete "The Oracle" | 36.5% | |
 | The Fugitive Complete Act 2 of "The Cain Killer" | 36.38% | 12/11/2019, 18:43:28 |
 | There's No I in Team Complete Act 3 of "The Cain Killer" | 35.39% | 12/11/2019, 19:45:06 |
 | Cogged Successfully complete "The Cain Killer" | 34.67% | 12/11/2019, 20:36:25 |
 | Take That, Jack! Protect a fellow agent | 34.24% | 12/11/2019, 20:14:05 |
| Filmed in Shakycam Use the camera to view all the numbers painted on the wall | 34.08% | |
 | A Question of Trust McAdams trusts you after a tense exchange in a car | 33.36% | 12/11/2019, 19:50:40 |
 | Deadbeat Dad The interrogation subject is coerced into talking | 32.26% | 12/11/2019, 18:43:32 |
 | The Good Sister Never lose any of Keith's trust in the Lakehouse | 31.97% | 12/11/2019, 18:07:04 |
 | Federal Protection Save Jetta during the undercover operation | 31.3% | 12/11/2019, 17:43:40 |
| Busy Work No one can get work done if you keep calling down to the office | 27.67% | |
 | Bad Attitude Establish a bad relationship with McAdams | 27.56% | 16/02/2018, 12:07:02 |
| Big Girl Now Complete "The Hangman" without texting Erica's dad | 27.35% | |
 | A Little Birdie Find the hidden Phoenix Online Logo | 25.01% | 14/11/2017, 15:32:47 |
 | Trying to Quit Refuse the coffee from Tess | 24.7% | 16/02/2018, 12:04:44 |
| Eye of the Beholder Two women see art very differently | 24.38% | |
| The Right Tool for the Job Thoroughly use cognition to help Keith with his problem | 23.49% | |
| Disgrace to the Bureau All Q&A puzzles are answered incorrectly | 23.34% | |
 | Stand Your Ground Fire at the car in the parking lot | 19.22% | 16/02/2018, 12:09:33 |
 | No Time For Games! Find the game within the game | 18.92% | 12/11/2019, 17:35:04 |
| Patron of the Arts Erica gets a close look at all the notable art | 18.26% | |
 | Avoidable Casualties Let Jetta die during the undercover operation | 17.29% | 12/11/2019, 17:45:15 |
| Guilt-Ridden Erica fails to save Scott from the trap | 17.19% | |
| PenPointing Try to place the pen in all possible places | 16.11% | |
| FBI Itch Ignore Terence's problem and find your own solution | 14.46% | |
 | Asphyxia You went a little too far and the interrogation subject passed out | 13.83% | 12/11/2019, 18:46:06 |
| Do A Barrel Roll! Dive clear of the car in the parking lot | 12.89% | |
 | A Question of Dust McAdams doesn’t trust you after a tense exchange in a car | 11.76% | 12/11/2019, 19:56:55 |
 | Moves Like Bauer Couldn't protect a fellow agent | 11.55% | 12/11/2019, 20:36:24 |
| McCoy, With a Donut, in the Jail Convince Robert to come to the station, get John's help, keep Robert in jail | 10.36% | |
| Good Cop/Bad Cop Force Robert's interrogation, get Sully's help, let Robert go free. | 10.04% | |
| Can't Stay Out of the Office Perform a character switch, starting somewhere outside | 9.32% |