Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | Joke Boat: Punching Down Compete against a joke that previously received zero points | 76.67% | |
 | Role Models: Unclassifiable Get a consolation role | 59.87% | |
 | Trivia Murder Party 2: Password (un)Protected Crack someone's password | 56.32% | |
| Role Models: That Ain't Me Everyone but you chooses you for a role | 47.52% | |
| Joke Boat: So brave You elect to perform every joke | 42.67% | |
| Role Models: Know Thyself Get a role you doubled down on | 40.04% | |
| Joke Boat: Giant Slayer You beat a joke that previously received unanimous votes in a 5-8 player game | 28.49% | |
 | Push the Button: Hacked Off Aliens win without using hacks | 22.06% | |
 | Joke Boat: Killed It Win every matchup | 21.14% | |
| Push the Button: Almost got ‘em The aliens win the game after a failed vote where they were properly isolated | 20.09% | |
| Push the Button: No Hit, Sherlock Aliens win in under five minutes | 13% | |
| Trivia Murder Party 2: Quiplash! Get all the votes in an old favorite | 11.29% | |
 | Role Models: Majorities Rule All players get a role without tiebreakers in a 6 player game | 10.11% | |
 | Dictionarium: I Wrote the Book Win all three rounds in a 3-5 player game | 7.75% | |
| Dictionarium: Run-On Write a sentence in Round 3 that uses the entire character limit | 5.78% | |
| Trivia Murder Party 2: Me and My Dad Survive the game (and then some) while wearing Father's Hat | 4.59% | |
| Trivia Murder Party 2: Runaways Win a game as the audience | 1.58% | |
| Push the Button: Skin of Your Teeth Humans win with one second or less remaining on the clock | 0.79% | |
| Dictionarium: Divinely Defined Your definition gets all the player votes and 90% of the audience | 0.39% | |
| Dictionarium: Mucus Ranch Use the phrase "mucus ranch" and win a round with it | 0% |