Achieved | Achievement | % of players | Unlock date |
|---|---|---|---|
 | James Howard's Story James Howard's Story | 84.44% | 26/01/2019, 00:25:00 |
 | Tutorial Completed Tutorial Completed | 75.04% | 26/01/2019, 00:39:43 |
 | Mary Martinez's Story Mary Martinez's Story | 50.49% | |
| Andrew Reed's Story Andrew Reed's Story | 49.36% | |
| The Secret Lies With Her The Secret Lies With Her | 37.71% | |
| Trisha Roberts' Story Trisha Roberts' Story | 34.83% | |
 | Guest's Lost Cap Guest's Lost Cap | 33.95% | |
| The Hidden Truth The Hidden Truth | 33.95% | |
| Best Friends Forever Best Friends Forever | 33.45% | |
| Dying Man's Letter Dying Man's Letter | 31.82% | |
| Scott's Secrets Scott's Secrets | 31.32% | |
| Here She Lies Here She Lies | 30.32% | |
| Oliver Gibson's Story Oliver Gibson's Story | 28.94% | |
| Scott Brooks' Story Scott Brooks' Story | 28.69% | |
| Sofia Miller's Story Sofia Miller's Story | 27.94% | |
| Bernard Hopkin's Story Bernard Hopkin's Story | 27.94% | |
| Dorothy Patterson's Story Dorothy Patterson's Story | 27.56% | |
| Vivian Roberts' Story Vivian Roberts' Story | 27.44% | |
| Steve Moss' Story Steve Moss' Story | 26.81% | |
| Matthew Brooks' Story Matthew Brooks' Story | 26.69% | |
| Bloody Knife Bloody Knife | 26.18% | |
| Wanda Tyler's Story Wanda Tyler's Story | 25.68% | |
| All Tools Found All Tools Found | 25.68% | |
| Charles Roberts' Story Charles Roberts' Story | 25.56% | |
| All Newspaper Articles Found All Newspaper Articles Found | 21.92% | |
| Truth Revealed Truth Revealed | 21.55% | |
| All Keys Found All Keys Found | 20.42% | |
| Derrick Tyler's Story Derrick Tyler's Story | 19.92% | |
| Missing Journalist Missing Journalist | 13.78% | |
 | You're Fired You're Fired | 13.15% | 26/01/2019, 00:05:49 |
| All Letters Found All Letters Found | 10.9% | |
| Case Unsolved Case Unsolved | 10.27% | |
| Completionist Completionist | 7.02% |